Are you a fan of strong, flavorful coffee? Are you looking for the perfect way to brew your morning cup? If so, then this blog post is for you! We’re here to compare the moka pot vs. French press. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced barista, we have all the information you need to make an informed decision. So read on and find out which brewer is best suited for your needs!
Table Of Contents
−- Overview of the two brewing methods
- The Moka pot
- The French press
- Here is a detailed comparison of these two methods:
- Moka Pot Vs. French Press: The full breakdown
- Is it better to use a French press or a Moka Pot?
Overview of the two brewing methods
If you truly prefer traditional brewing methods, you know how valuable it is to have a French Press and Moka pot in the house. The two methods originated in Italy and brewed strong, rich, bold coffee. While both are from Italy, their methods and resulting brew and quality set them apart.
The Moka pot and French press are two popular brewing methods, each offering different benefits and challenges.
The Moka pot is a stove-top coffee maker that produces coffee by using pressure to pass boiling water through ground coffee.
On the other hand, the French press uses an immersion technique in which the coffee grounds are steeped in hot water, resulting in a full-bodied cup of coffee.
A French press makes coffee by steeping coarse grinds in hot water. A Moka pot uses pressure to extract coffee. It works like an espresso maker.
Both of these methods are relatively affordable, making them accessible to coffee connoisseurs and home brewing enthusiasts alike.
The choice between the French press and the Moka pot boils down to your preference for coffee. Sure, each has pros and downsides, but in many ways, they are just two distinct methods of brewing coffee.
However, to give you some insight into how to choose one or the other, let’s break them down based on how they work and the benefits and drawbacks of each.
The Moka pot
Moka pots are also referred to as stovetop espresso makers because of their concentrated and creamy brew. The pot is partitioned into three chambers: one for grounds, one for water, and one that holds the resulting brew. They are mostly made of stainless steel and aluminum.
How it works
Place a Moka pot on your stove, fill the bottom chamber with water, and bring it to a boil. As the water starts to boil, the steam travels up and through the coffee grounds. The resulting coffee is then sent via a spout and collected at the top. You will end up with an intense and strong cup of coffee.
Here are the steps:
- Add water to the boiler (bottom chamber)
- Place the metal filter (middle chamber)
- Pour finely ground coffee on the filter
- Tightly screw the upper chamber
- Place the Moka pot on your stove
- Bring the water to boil. Steam will travel up through the coffee grounds extracting coffee
Pros
- Easy to use
- Makes a very rich and thick coffee
- Portable
- The aluminum body helps to retain heat
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Requires a pricey grinder to produce a fine texture
- All parameters need to be accounted for ahead of time, which takes practice
- Difficult to control quality from brew to brew
The French press
A French press is a common gadget in many homes today. Since the initial design, it has gone through many improvements. The modern designs are very simple and easy to use. You will also hear some people calling it cafetière à piston, cafeteria, coffee plunger, press pot, or coffee press.
How it works
A French press has a plunger, a carafe, and a lid. To brew, place coffee in the carafe, pour in hot water, and wait for the coffee ground to steep for at least 4 minutes. Now press the plunger down slowly, and you can enjoy your brew with any accompaniment. You will get a richer and more full-bodied cup of coffee.
Here are the steps:
- Boil water to around 205°F
- Grind the beans to a coarse grind size
- Add the coarse coffee grounds to the carafe and pour hot water
- Bloom for 45 seconds and then stir
- Steep the coffee for about 4 minutes
- Push down the plunger slowly to filter the coffee
- Enjoy!
Pros
- Allow you to make coffee according to your taste. For example, you can adjust brew time, temperature, and filtering process.
- You get a delicious and robust coffee
- Portable
- Right size. Big enough to prepare enough coffee for your family.
Cons:
- Fragile (made of glass)
- Cleaning up can be a little bit of a task
Here is a detailed comparison of these two methods:
| | French Press | Moka Pot |
| Origin | Italy, 1929 | Italy, 1933 |
| Grind Size | Coarse | Fine |
| Brewing Method | Steeping | Pressure |
| How to Make Coffee | Pour beans into the carafe, add hot water, steep for 4 minutes, and plunge | Fill the boiler with water, add coffee grinds to the filter and place on the heat source to brew |
| Portability | Easy to pack, put the fragile glass put them at a disadvantage. | They are more portable, plus they are made from aluminum or steel materials which makes them almost indestructible. |
| Brew Time | 5 minutes | 5-10 minutes |
| Brew Size | 2-10 (8-oz cups) | 1-18 (2 oz cups) |
| Resulting Brew | Full-bodied and full flavor | Strong and sharp |
| Average Price Range | $10-$70 | $30-$100 |
Moka Pot Vs. French Press: The full breakdown
We’d be here for days if I compared every feature of these two goods. That said, let’s take a quick look at the qualities that should influence your decision most.
1 . The brewing process
The brewing process for the Moka Pot and French Press can vary, but both of these coffee-making tools are used to make great-tasting cups of coffee.
Moka Pot Brewing Process
The Moka Pot brewing process is a unique approach to preparing coffee. It uses steam pressure to extract the flavor from the coffee grounds, producing a rich, syrupy coffee that is reminiscent of Italian espresso.
Most time will be spent boiling the water in a Moka pot. Once the water reaches a boil, the extraction process is quick. You won’t want to leave the pot unattended, though, because it’s very likely that you’ll wind up with bitter coffee.
French Press Brewing Process
The French Press brewing process differs from the Moka Pot in several ways. Unlike the Moka Pot, which uses pressure to extract a strong, espresso-like coffee, the French Press uses steeping. This involves immersing the grounds in hot water for several minutes to extract flavor and caffeine, resulting in a creamy, full-bodied cup of coffee.
Nothing can be prepared ahead of time for a French press. Each batch of coffee should be ground as soon as feasible. Separately, the water must be heated to just below boiling, and the steeping and plunging operation will take around five minutes.
WINNER: While it’s a close call, the Moka pot wins this round since it takes less time to prepare, brew, and clean up.
2. Brewing Speed
Brewing speed is an important factor to consider when comparing the Moka Pot and French Press.
Moka Pot
The Moka Pot uses the pressure method to brew the coffee within 5 to 7 minutes, making it a relatively faster brewing option than the French Press. The Moka Pot offers a speedier alternative for those who don’t have a lot of time to spare. With this in mind, Moka Pot can be a great choice for those who are looking for an efficient and easy brewing option.
French Press
The French Press also brews coffee relatively quickly compared to the Moka Pot, but not quite as fast. When brewing a cup of coffee with the French Press, it should take about four to five minutes for the coffee to steep properly. The total for boiling, grinding, and steeping should take up to 10-15 minutes; that being said, the amount of time it takes to brew can vary depending on the coarseness of the grounds and the amount of coffee used.
Winner
The Moka Pot brews more quickly than the French Press as it relies on using steam pressure to extract the coffee, while the French Press needs to steep for a few minutes.
3. Labor intensity
When it comes to the labor intensity of brewing coffee with a Moka Pot and a French Press, the two methods differ in many ways.
Moka Pot
The labor intensity of a Moka Pot is relatively low, with just a few simple steps required in the brewing process. To begin, fill the bottom chamber of the pot with cold, filtered water, without exceeding the safety valve.
Next, fill the filter basket with ground coffee and insert it into the bottom chamber, ensuring that it is firmly in place. Place the pot on your stove and heat until you can hear a bubbling sound. Finally, remove from heat once you hear a hissing sound, and enjoy your freshly brewed coffee!
French press
The French Press is a bit time-consuming and requires more effort than the Moka Pot. It involves a bit of manual work, as the user has to press down the plunger at the end of the brew. However, this labor intensity is often seen as a plus by some coffee connoisseurs, as it gives them more control over the final product. Moreover, it can also be quite forgiving if some of the steps are not followed correctly.
Winner
The brewing process for both a Moka Pot and a French Press have their respective differences, and this extends to the labor intensity of the processes. The Moka Pot requires more attention throughout the whole process, whereas the French Press is more prep-intensive. With the Moka Pot, you need to measure out the grinds carefully, monitor the pressure levels as it brews, and watch as it boils.
With a French Press on the other hand, you need to measure out your coffee beans and grind them to the right consistency before immersing them in hot water. \The Moka Pot is also quite variable in terms of quality, so you need to make sure everything is just right if you want a great cup. In contrast, the French Press is more forgiving in terms of quality and far simpler to brew with since you can use volume measurements instead of mass.
4. Strength of coffee
The strength of coffee produced by the Moka Pot and French Press is a key factor in deciding between the two brewing methods.
Moka Pot
The Moka Pot produces a very rich and syrupy cup of coffee with a bold flavor and real depth. It uses pressure to extract a strong, espresso-like coffee. The pressure used for this brewing method means that you can create high-quality cups of coffee with less time and effort than with a French press.
French Press
The French press is a popular method of brewing coffee that uses a plunger-like device to steep the grounds in hot water. Unlike the Moka pot, which passes hot water through the grounds, the French press allows the grounds to steep in the hot water for a predetermined amount of time. This results in a strong cup of coffee with a bold flavor.
Additionally, because no paper filters are used with the French press, some of the natural oils from the beans are retained in the brew, resulting in a richer taste. Furthermore, with the French press, you can control how much time you steep your grounds and how fine or coarse you grind them. This allows you to customize your cup of coffee according to your own personal preferences.
Winner
The strength of the coffee brewed by the Moka pot and French press is one of the key differences between these two methods. The Moka pot produces a stronger, more concentrated cup of coffee that is similar in strength to espresso. On the other hand, the French press produces a less intense cup of coffee that still has a rich flavor.
The amount of caffeine in each cup differs as well, as espresso contains more caffeine per volume than Moka pot coffee. It is important to keep in mind the different strengths of the two when deciding which brewing process is best for you.
If you want strong coffee, Moka pot is the winner
5. The Quality
Moka pots brew coffee under pressure, similar to the process used to make espresso. On the other hand, Moka pots extract at a far lower pressure than espresso machines. Thus they aren’t quite a replacement. However, it provides a far more concentrated brew than drip or French press. It is also possible to achieve a touch of sweet crema in a Moka pot brew.
The French Press relies on the oils and tastes roasted in the bean to make the greatest brew, which allows for much more flavor variety. Steeping also leaves a thick, often oily mouth feel without necessarily adding flavor.
This is something that some individuals appreciate. Thus it is a matter of personal preference. French presses extract an incredibly subtle taste and provide a full-bodied sensation to even lighter roasted coffees.
6. The price comparison: Initial, operational, durability
When it comes to the initial investment, Moka Pots are usually the slightly more expensive option compared to a French Press. Electric Moka pots can be much more expensive than manual models, but this might be worth it, keeping in mind all the time and effort saved.
That being said, both brewing methods are relatively affordable and are excellent for coffee connoisseurs to improve their skills. Ultimately, it all boils down to personal preference and budget.
Moka Pot
Moka Pots tend to be the slightly more expensive option, ranging in price from $15 to $50 depending on the brand, size, and material.
The Moka Pot has no mechanical or electrical components, so there are no ongoing expenses.
The Moka Pot is made from stainless steel and is designed to last for years, and the French Press is made from glass or stainless steel and can also last for a long time. However, the Moka Pot does have mechanical parts that can corrode and break over time, so it may require more maintenance than the French Press.
French press
On the other hand, you can find a French Press for as little as $15 and as much as $50. Ultimately, the decision of which one to buy should come down to factors such as taste preferences and brewing speed.
The French Press, however, needs to be replaced every few years due to wear and tear on the plunger.
Winner
Both. When it comes to durability, both the Moka Pot and French Press offer a reliable brew. If you’re making a decision based solely on pricing, keep in mind that both pieces of equipment are in the same price range.
6. Cleaning Ease
Cleaning and Maintenance: Moka Pots and French Presses both require regular cleaning and maintenance to ensure proper functioning, but they differ in how much time and effort is required.
Moka Pot
Cleaning and maintenance for Moka pots require special attention. Unlike French Presses, Moka pots should never be cleaned with soap or put in the dishwasher. To keep a Moka pot in top shape, it’s best to clean it with a mild detergent and rinse it thoroughly after every brew.
If you have an aluminum Moka pot, you can use coffee-cleaning detergents or descalers to remove coffee oils from the material. Keeping your Moka pot clean will ensure you get the best possible taste from your coffee without any bitterness or strange flavors.
Because the stainless steel/aluminum pot gets incredibly hot, allow the Moka Pot to cool completely before cleaning to avoid burning your hands. After that, discard the grounds and rinse with lukewarm water. It’s also a good idea to let it air dry before storing it.
French Press
Cleaning a French press is simple, but the plunger must be thoroughly cleaned. Leavened-over grinds produce harsh coffee, so be sure to remove them entirely. After that, rinse the base with warm water, and you’re done.
Cleaning and maintenance for French presses are relatively simple and easy. All the pieces come apart, are easily accessible, and can even be put in the dishwasher. The two-part process of cleaning is straightforward and involves removing the old grounds, hand washing with warm water, and assembling the press without putting any coffee in it.
With proper maintenance, a French press can last a lifetime and will ensure you get consistent and delicious cups of coffee every time.
Winner
When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, both the Moka pot and French press are easy to clean. However, the Moka pot may require more attention and maintenance if you use an aluminum material.
Additionally, the Moka pot requires regular descaling to remove calcium buildup, while the French press requires more frequent attention and cleaning of the plunger mechanism.
French Press may leave some leftover grounds stuck inside, but that shouldn’t take too much effort to clean. To avoid an excessive accumulation of limescale in either coffee maker, it is advised not to use scouring pads or abrasive products during cleaning.
Even with the little annoyance of residual grounds sticking to the plunger, the French press is less picky than the Moka Pot. Therefore it takes the victory.
7. Capacity: Cup Size and Output
When it comes to cup size and output, the Moka pot and the French press have their distinct advantages and disadvantages. Moka pots typically produce a smaller cup size and less output than French presses.
Moka pot
Having determined your desired cup size, it’s important to measure the right size for your needs. Moka pots come in various sizes – get one that makes enough brew for your needs. If you get a Bialetti stovetop espresso maker, you can choose from 1, 3, 6, 9, or 12-cup sizes.
Each “cup” is equivalent to approximately 60 ml, or 2 fluid ounces. A standard cup in a Moka pot is about two ounces (or a traditional espresso shot size). Generally, a Moka Pot’s cup size should match the number of people sharing the coffee. For example, a 3-cup Moka Pot should be used when making coffee for two people.
French Press
On the other hand, French presses come in larger sizes that can make up to 12 cups of coffee. The ideal and most popular option for smaller households is the 3-cup model, which makes about 200 ml or 6½ fl oz of coffee at 16 cm or 6 inches in height.
If you are using a Bodum French Press to make coffee, you can fill it with water to the line indicated inside to find out how many cups it makes.
Winner
Winner: As such, if you need to make large batches of coffee quickly and don’t want to sacrifice quality, the French press might be your best bet. On the other hand, if you prefer a smaller cup size or only need one cup at a time, the Moka pot may be the perfect solution.
8. Taste Comparison
When it comes to the tasting comparison between the Moka Pot and the French Press, it’s a close call.
Moka Pot
The Moka Pot produces a very rich and flavorful cup of coffee that is more concentrated than regular drip coffee. It is also more energizing than drip coffee, and it pairs well with milk or other creamers.
The Moka Pot is bright and sweet, making you forget you’re not drinking espresso. And if you do it well, you’ll also get some of that smooth, rich crema on top.
The Moka Pot offers a much punchier cup of coffee, akin to an Italian espresso.
French press
On the other hand, the French Press leaves you with a more mellow and balanced flavor profile.
Thick, rich, and powerful. The grounds and water remain in contact until the end of the brewing cycle, when you press the plunger down, resulting in a strong-flavored coffee. Just be cautious of any leftover grounds!
Winner
Controversial – The Moka pot produces a substantially stronger cup of coffee (similar to an ‘Italian espresso’). The French Press produces a smooth, fragrant blend.
While the Moka pot is highly energizing, the French press provides a more balanced taste when drunk black.
The decision between a Moka Pot and French Press comes down to preference. Both devices are capable of making delicious coffee, but the Moka Pot will offer a much punchier cup of espresso-like coffee, while the French Press will give you more variety and a more balanced cup of coffee.
Is it better to use a French press or a Moka Pot?
Both make high-quality coffee, so deciding which is better is a matter of personal preference. However, we can tell you that the French press is, in some respects, the simplest method to master. This is because you have greater control over the correct espresso.
In a French press, you may adjust the number of grounds used and the steeping period. You’re at the mercy of your stovetop in a Moka pot, though getting the real grind is still vital.
Moka pot is the way to go if you want something robust and close to espresso. Choose a French press if you like a robust brew and don’t mind some grounds in your coffee.
Moka pots require greater skill and a longer trial-and-error time to get the perfect brew. However, once you’ve mastered it, you’ll be able to make both weaker and stronger brews at home with near-espresso-quality extraction.
If you enjoy experimenting while still having complete control over how your coffee comes out, I recommend the Moka pot. Here are the t op Moka pot models. Bialetti, the creator of the Moka pot, has been delighting customers with the Moka Express for many years.
Oh, you’ve been cursed with an Induction stove?
Bialetti has you covered with the sleek tiny Bialetti Venus Moka pot: designed specifically for induction cooktops. Because of the design, you can and should take it camping (if you have a portable induction heat plate, that is). With a six-cup volume (per serving), you’ll be able to keep your entire household – or camping – high (on caffeine).
However, if the simplicity of the French Press tempts you, this list contains the finest French press models as voted by us.
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links. Remember to support us by purchasing through the Amazon/Walmart/Impact Radius links provided. Last update on 2024-04-29 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Disclosure: No compensation or free products were received in exchange for writing this review.
Editorial Staff
The editorial staff at Crazy Coffee Crave is a team of coffee enthusiasts & Baristas who enjoy the one thing we all think about as soon as we get up in the morning. Trusted by thousands of readers worldwide.
