What Is the Difference Between a Keurig vs. Traditional Coffee Maker?

crazy by Editorial Staff | Updated on April 1st, 2023

Do you like the old-fashioned methods, or do you have a machine that uses K-cups?

If you don’t have a Keurig, you might be thinking about the benefits and drawbacks.

keurig vs coffee maker

Which produces the greatest results with a Keurig vs. a coffee maker? 

Here, we’ll look at the benefits and drawbacks of both to help you make an informed decision.

The benefits and drawbacks of K-Cups


Keurig machines have certain distinct advantages over other methods of brewing coffee, as well as some obvious negatives.

We shall examine these elements in further depth in relation to certain brewing methods below, but in general, the key benefits are convenience and the availability of a large variety of decent coffees and other drinks.

The main drawbacks are the expense – both for the machine and the pods – the fact that customers are “locked in” to K-Cups, restricting their options, and the environmental difficulties associated with literally billions of K-Cup pods ending up in waste sites each year.

Let’s compare Keurig devices to other methods of brewing coffee.

Keurig vs. Conventional coffee maker

We’ll presume “standard coffee maker” refers to an electric drip coffee machine. 

A drip coffee maker is incredibly easy to use and consistently produces wonderful coffee – as long as you use the correct dose and good coffee in the first place.

However, because there are more variables, there is a greater possibility of getting a terrible cup than if you use a Keurig.

This is the type of machine that Keurig was created to replace, and for one reason only. The coffee will be fine if you make it using a drip machine and drink it immediately.

If you leave it to stew on the hotplate, it will become bitter and nasty.

These machines are significantly less expensive than Keurig coffee makers. The majority of Keurig machines cost at least four times as much. Buying coffee beans or ground coffee is also far less expensive than buying K-Cups; K-Cups can be up to 2-3 times more expensive.

The benefits of K-Cup

  • a good selection of coffees
  • Always high-quality beverages

The benefits of using a Drip Machine

  • Much less expensive to purchase and use.
  • You have more freedom to use any coffee you like.
  • There will be no plastic waste, and there will be less pollution.

Keurig coffee maker vs. Drip coffee maker

In this context, “drip” refers to a single-cup pour-over drip coffee maker. These offer similar advantages and disadvantages to the drip machine but have the distinct advantage of being able to create higher-quality coffee.

If you are a true coffee connoisseur, this is most likely your preferred method. If you appreciate purchasing and enjoying costly specialty coffees, utilizing a pour-over drip is one of the greatest methods to bring out the complex and nuanced tastes for which you pay extra money.

Making the perfect cup, such as this one, is a fine skill that requires effort to master. The ritual of preparing the equipment, measuring, and gently pouring is a vital aspect of the procedure for some. It is an unneeded annoyance for others.

It all boils down to whether you value speed and convenience or want to brew slowly. Both methods are equally valid.

The benefits of K-Cup

  • Rapidity and practicality
  • Consistently excellent cup of coffee
  • It does not require any talent to operate.

The benefits of pour-over drip

  • Allows you greater versatility in brewing exceptional coffee with specialty beans.
  • Coffee preparation is a pleasurable process.
  • Much less expensive than a Keurig machine.
  • Reduced environmental effect

Ground coffee vs. Keurig

K-Cups have a significant advantage over buying coffee beans, especially ground coffee, in that they keep fresh for a considerably longer amount of time.

When green coffee beans are roasted, a process known as the Maillard reaction occurs, which produces the flavors and fragrances of coffee (this is the same process that causes toast to taste different from bread and cooked steak to have a different flavor and texture to raw meat).

Freshly roasted coffee beans contain a significant amount of carbon dioxide, which is rapidly released during the first few days following roasting. Following that, they begin to release CO2 more slowly.

After a week to two weeks, there has been enough CO2 released to allow oxidation to commence. When oxidation occurs, the flavor of the beans begins to deteriorate, and there is little you can do to stop it.

The enormously higher surface area of pre-ground coffee permits oxidization to proceed at a significantly faster rate, implying that ground coffee deteriorates far faster than whole beans.

The only thing required for oxidization to occur is oxygen. When coffee is packed into a K-Cup pod, the oxygen is totally excluded, effectively putting the coffee in “stasis” and halting oxidization.

As a result, premium coffee in a K-Pod will stay fresher for a considerably longer period of time. This means that if you just drink coffee on occasion, investing in a Keurig could be a good option because your coffee will stay fresher for much longer.

If you buy coffee beans or grounds and don’t finish it within a week or two, you’ll be sipping stale coffee. However, if you are merely a casual drinker, you may not want to invest the money on a machine that you will not use very often.

Keurig overview:


Keurig, the original coffee pod maker, is the king of single-serve coffee brewing equipment. The Keurig machines were an instant hit, prompting coffee bean firms to seek out partnerships to put their coffee into K-Cup pods.

Despite the fact that the market has been saturated with competitive single-serve makers and coffee pods, Keurig remains a hugely popular brand. The company has also dabbled in the tea sector, offering hundreds of herbal and classic tea pods.

Keurig’s K-Cups may be obtained in almost any place, and practically every coffee and tea brand has a K-Cup accessible, so new Keurig consumers can continue to enjoy their preferred brew.

Their machines are likewise widely available, ranging from low-cost models to more expensive, feature-rich ones. They also offer a model that can brew a whole pot of coffee, but their main focus is on coffee pods.

How Does It Work?

Using a Keurig is simple because they are meant to be user-friendly. The Keurig operates by adding one cup of water if it has a one-cup water reservoir or adding water to the larger reservoirs found in other models, inserting a coffee pod into the coffee pod slot, selecting a cup size, and pushing the brew button.

Because not all Keurig machines are the same, make sure you select the correct cup size as well as brew strength if your model allows it. Most Keurig machines are identical in operation, making it quite simple to utilize machines other than your own.

How much does a Keurig cost?

The cost of a Keurig machine, as well as the cost of the pods, is likely to be a major consideration for most individuals considering purchasing a Keurig – so how much do they cost?

The K-Mini K15 is the smallest and least expensive Keurig. Aside from that, various models are available, each with its own set of characteristics, such as the capacity to pour carafes of coffee.

The Keurig K-Elite is the most recent model, and it is a hot and cold combo maker.

Is a Keurig worth the money?

The question of whether a Keurig is worth purchasing is heavily dependent on you and your priorities because, as previously said, Keurig machines have some distinct advantages over other ways of brewing, as well as some drawbacks.

The simplicity and convenience of using a Keurig are the key draws. The Keurig is hard to beat if you want your coffee ready promptly and with the least amount of bother in the morning as you rush out the door.

Another significant advantage is that K-Cups last far longer than normal beans or ground coffee. If you find that your coffee goes stale because you don’t finish it quickly enough, a Keurig could be an excellent option.

With a Keurig, you know you’ll get a quick, fresh, and delicious cup every time.

However, there are several significant disadvantages to having a Keurig, not the least of which is the cost. Keurig coffee makers are far more expensive than normal drip machines or other brewing techniques; after the initial investment, you will also spend significantly more on pods than regular beans or grinds.

Another significant disadvantage is being constrained to buy just coffee offered in pods. While there is presently a wide variety available – both using official K-Cups and other “rebel” brands – you still don’t have the freedom to buy whatever you like that a traditional method provides.

Watch this video to learn how to hack a Keurig 2.0 to accept “rebel” pods.

It should be noted that Keurig has just introduced reusable K-Cups in an attempt to address this issue.

The third important issue with K-Cups is the negative influence they have on the environment. If you care about the environment, using what has been called as “the most wasteful sort of coffee, there is” is difficult to rationalize.

In a word, if you value speed and efficiency, don’t have time to waste making coffee, and don’t mind paying the extra expense, a Keurig can be a good investment.

If you want to save money while still enjoying the freedom and creativity that conventional methods provide, a Keurig may not be the best choice.

When should you buy a Keurig?

One obvious limitation of the Keurig is that it cannot create numerous cups at the same time unless you get a special Keurig model that includes both traditional and coffee pod brewers.

They are also often more expensive than standard coffee makers and other coffee makers in general.

Keurig machines are infamous for being difficult to clean and maintain, but it is necessary to do so in order to prevent mold and mineral development. Most K-cups are also not recyclable unless properly cleaned, making them less eco-friendly than they could be.


  • Instead of a complete pot, this recipe yields one cup.
  • Excellent for individuals who simply require one or two cups.
  • Not only does it make coffee, but it also makes tea and hot cocoa.
  • In general, it is faster than making a whole pot.
  • Machines and K-Cups are widely accessible.
  • Ideal for use in offices and waiting rooms.


  • Making numerous cups using a single-serve brewer is difficult.
  • More difficult to clean and maintain
  • More pricey than the majority of coffee makers
  • Not all K-Cups can be recycled.

With the exception of their single-serve devices, traditional coffee makers can brew any sort of ground coffee for many persons at once, but nearly all Keurig single-pod brewers can only brew one cup at a time.

Traditional coffee machines range in price from $15 to $185, depending on their functions and brewing capabilities. Their most basic coffee maker costs roughly $15, making it ideal for those searching for a low-cost brewer.

Coffee makers and their types of overview

A man in the kitchen pouring a mug of hot filtered coffee from a glass pot. Having breakfast in the morning

There are numerous types of conventional coffee machines. To name a few, here is a short list:

  1. Coffee machines that drip.
  2. Single-cup pour-over brewers
  3. Coffee presses with a French press.
  4. Coffee makers for the stovetop.

How does it work?

Most coffee makers operate similarly to other classic coffee brewers, which is convenient for individuals who are already accustomed to them.

Simply fill the reservoir with water, pouring up to the desired cup line; place a coffee filter in the basket and fresh coffee grounds; select your brew strength; and push the brew button. Because most coffee makers use the same sort of coffee brewer, these steps should be applicable.

What is it good for?

Traditional coffee makers are wonderful for creating numerous cups of coffee at once, which is useful if you’re hosting a party or don’t want to create a new cup every time you want more coffee.

They can use any sort of coffee you desire, unlike Keurig requires the use of a reusable coffee pod.

Traditional coffee makers are less expensive than Keurig machines and provide a far wider choice with a wider price range to fit your budget. Keurig machines, on the other hand, are not as cheap unless you choose the smallest model.

Traditional coffee makers are pretty simple to use, even if you must set up the filter and coffee grounds manually. They may be a little messier than Keurigs, but you can control how much or how little coffee grounds you add. They’re also easy to clean.

When should you opt for traditional drip coffee?

One disadvantage of carafe-style coffee makers is that they take longer to brew a full pot than a Keurig does. They’re just not as convenient as Keurig machines, especially if you’re pressed for time in the morning.

Another issue is that coffee makers make the same sort of coffee throughout the entire pot, but Keurig makers give users the option of selecting the type of coffee they desire. They aren’t as versatile as Keurig coffee makers, which allow users to substitute tea or hot cocoa for coffee.


  • It produces a full pot of coffee.
  • Any variety of ground coffee can be used.
  • It is relatively simple to use.
  • Excellent for company or gatherings.
  • Keurig is less expensive.
  • a wider range of coffee makers


  • It can take some time to brew a complete pot.
  • It makes the same type of coffee as a full pot.
  • Not as handy as a single-serve maker.
  • They are not as adaptable as pod brewers

Which one is the best match for you?

With all of the information available about coffee makers and the many coffee machines, it is difficult to determine which coffee maker is best for you. Here, I’ll walk you through a few steps you can take before determining which coffee maker is best for you.

1. Make a budget first

Purchasing a coffee maker for yourself is a long-term investment, and you want to ensure that anyone you choose will not break the bank. Consider your everyday requirements to pick one that fits your lifestyle.

Consider your income as well because certain coffee machines necessitate the purchase of accessories on a regular basis.

2. The value of brewing temperature

A coffee machine that can brew at high heat will produce the best taste of coffee from your coffee beans. Rich flavors emerge when the coffee machine can brew the coffee at temperatures ranging from 196°F to 205°F.

Typically, you will check the temperature of the coffee maker on the box or online. If this information is lacking, you should avoid that one.

3. Determine the number of cups of coffee you consume.

If you drink two cups of coffee each day, a single-serve machine might be the best option for you. If you’re a coffee addict who needs numerous cups of coffee throughout the day, you may prefer a classic coffee maker with coffee pots that hold up to 12-cups.

4. Consider the daily cleaning.

If you have a hectic schedule, you might not have time to clean your coffee machine on a regular basis. Make an assessment of your lifestyle and conduct a study on each coffee machine’s cleaning procedure.


There are numerous comparisons to be made between the Keurig machine and a typical coffee maker. It would be helpful if you broke down each of their various categories of benefits and negatives.

Sit down and consider what would be more suitable for your lifestyle. What can you afford on your salary?

With all of this knowledge, I hope the guide I’ve provided can assist you in making the best option for yourself. If you have any questions or suggestions, please leave them in the comments section below. We appreciate hearing from you!

Take out your notebook and begin collecting all of the information you require. You can use the questions in this article to aid you along the way.

Keurig coffee makers are here to stay, whether you like them or not. They are pricey, but they are quite useful, and you can’t beat their ease of use.

Perhaps if Keurig could tackle the environmental issues, they would be more acceptable to many people.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links. Remember to support us by purchasing through the Amazon/Walmart/Impact Radius links provided. Last update on 2024-05-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Disclosure: No compensation or free products were received in exchange for writing this review.


Editorial Staff

The editorial staff at Crazy Coffee Crave is a team of coffee enthusiasts & Baristas who enjoy the one thing we all think about as soon as we get up in the morning. Trusted by thousands of readers worldwide.