9 Best Organic K Cup Coffee Pods Reviewed

crazy by Editorial Staff | Updated on June 26th, 2022

Many of us rely greatly on coffee’s flavor.

If you’re into Keurig, you don’t want to be left out while the pour-over enthusiast might have every technique at their disposal. There are a few best organic k cup coffee that you can buy for your Keurig machine.

organic coffee

When you choose organic coffee, you are pampering your taste buds and your entire health.

The best organic k-cup coffee

1. Real good coffee organic k-cups

In blind taste testing, the Real Good Coffee brand outperformed big competitors such as Starbucks, Peet’s, and Green Mountain.

It lives up to its name: it’s delicious, owing to organic Arabica coffee beans farmed in Sumatra, South and Central America.

The Real Good Coffee brand is organically certified. It is manufactured as a medium roast, providing just the right amount of caffeine for those looking for a decent balance.

These popular organic coffee k cups are intended to work with any Keurig machine.

Another appealing aspect is that it comes in a variety pack, letting you sample several tastes such as French Roast, Donut Shop, and Breakfast Blend.

If you want a tasty roast that also supports environmental well-being, you’ll love Real Good Coffee.

2. SF Bay Coffee one-cup Organic Rainforest Blend

The Organic Rainforest Blend is one of five K-Cup flavors available at the SF Bay Coffee OneCUP location. The beans are sourced from Central America and are medium-dark roasted before being ground and placed into the K-Cups. The dark chocolaty flavor blended with sweet berries can be attributed to the Central American roots.

Because of the 12, 36, and 80-cup pack sizes, this K-Cup product is suitable for many homes. It’s also better for coffee enthusiasts who prefer full-bodied beverages because of its medium-dark roast.

Having 12, 36, and 80-cup pack sizes, in our perspective, makes it easier to sell to a broader market. One reason is that it appeals to a wider range of budgetary possibilities. Next, whether you live alone or with a large family, there is a pack for everyone. In addition, the K-Cups are certified by California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF), an organization that bears the same weight as the USDA regarding organic certifications.

A recurring issue on our list is that light-roast coffee drinkers are underrepresented in K-Cup selections, and the SF Bay Coffee OneCUP Organic Rainforest Blend is no exception. Furthermore, certain K-Cups tend to explode while brewing. This can cause the brewing process to be interrupted or introduce some of the grinds into the coffee. It might also be inconvenient to clean up after such an occurrence.

3. Peet’s organic k-cups coffee

Peet’s coffee has a fantastic fresh taste and is full of flavor. It is USDA organically certified.

USDA stands for United States Department of Agriculture. When coffee is certified as organic under this category, it signifies that great care has been taken to ensure the quality of the ingredients used.

Because Peet’s organic coffee satisfies USDA standards, no chemicals are used in its ingredients.

Furthermore, the farming practices employed are the most environmentally beneficial. 

4. Organic coffee co – java love organic k-cups

If you’re seeking another fantastic organic coffee alternative, Organic Coffee Co. will not disappoint.

Their coffee, sourced from Indonesia and Latin America, has a delectably syrupy flavor.

Organic Coffee Co is certified organic and suitable with most Keuring 1.0 and 2.0 brewers, in addition to its delectable flavor.

Their premium coffee is manufactured from Arabica beans grown at high altitudes. It is also hand-picked in the shade of local trees.

The delicate flavor of milk chocolate entered our mouths. The creaminess of caramel comes next and has a slight nutmeg flavor.

While mild isn’t always a negative thing, we like more flavor.

5. Newman’s organic k-cups

If you’re unsure whether you want caffeinated or decaffeinated coffee, Newman’s Own offers three excellent options: French roast, special blend, or special decaf.

As a fair trade and USDA organic certified coffee, this powerful mix provides more than simply a fantastic taste: it also passes kosher criteria.

Pack size options ranging from 32 to 96 mean you’re covered if you drink many cups of coffee daily. The same is true if the pack is designed to serve numerous people in the household. We also enjoyed that there are four variable flavor options, which means you may mix and match flavors on consecutive orders if you like. Finally, it is not limited to organic coffee drinkers. It is Fair Trade Certified and caters to Jews.


Consistency could be an issue. We discovered that you could enjoy the flavor of one pod but be completely disappointed by the next. This is especially true for the decaf, which tastes a little watered down, in our opinion. Nonetheless, the flavor was accurate more than 90% of the time in the other batches. Another disadvantage is the lack of light roast possibilities. As a result, if you prefer non-traditional coffee flavors, the Newman’s Own Organics Coffee Pods may not be suitable for you.

6. Amazonfresh Organic K-Cups

You read that right: Amazon now sells organic coffee. These fragrant and satisfying k cups are from Peru’s luscious mountains.

They are USDA organic and fair trade certified, so you can enjoy a nutritious medium roast coffee made under decent working circumstances.

This medium roast has a smooth finish that will have you wanting a second cup as soon as you finish the first.

The aroma of fresh Peruvian coffee will undoubtedly wake you up and urge you to face the day with zeal and enthusiasm.

We appreciated having the option of sourcing coffee from Peru or Sumatra. If you’re unsure or are still new to coffees and their many flavors and scents, you can try both before settling on one. Of course, these two have dual flavor profiles, which is due to the differing roast varieties. The Peruvian has a smoother flavor, while the Sumatran has a deeper, more intense flavor.

Having addressed the needs of coffee consumers who prefer dark and medium roasts, you have to feel sorry for light-roast coffee enthusiasts, who are once again left out. In addition, unlike the previous K-Cup offers, the AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups pack is not Kosher certified.

As a result, Jews are unable to use these pods. Next, because all 80 K-Cups are packed loosely in the shipping box, we discovered that at least one leak is usual. Finally, no smaller pack sizes are available.

7. Caza trail organic extra bold coffee pods

The Caza Trail Organic Extra Bold Coffee Pods come next, and they, too, use Arabica coffee, albeit the origins of the beans are unknown. Before being put in K-Cups and transported to you, it is medium-roasted. In addition, 100 K-Cups are included in the box.

Those who can’t decide between light-roasted coffee’s floral flavors and the body of darker roasts have a feasible option in the medium-roasted Caza Trail Organic Extra Bold Coffee Pods. Furthermore, because it is compatible with both 1.0 and 2.0 brewers, it will operate with any machine you possess.

Because each package contains 100 K-Cups, you may use your daily coffee limit without worrying about running out. In addition, like Newman’s Organics Coffee Pods, It is Kosher and can consume the coffee without violating their religious convictions. Finally, this coffee’s medium roast, in our opinion, works well if you appreciate both strong coffees that are distinctive of dark roasts and floral, fruity tones that are more common in light roasts.

While it strikes a decent middle ground between flavors, some drinkers prefer robust or floral tones, which this K-Cup coffee option does not provide. In addition, we found significant flavor discrepancies in this product and its predecessor, the Newman’s Own Organics Coffee Pods.

One batch may be as stated, while another may contain undertones of bitterness here and there. This option may be a tall order for buyers who want the same coffee flavor every time they deliver.

8. Cameron’s coffee organic breakfast blend

The Cameron’s Coffee Organic Breakfast Blend is the only light-roast choice on the list. It’s also available in a dark roast, while medium roasts aren’t included. Each K-Cup costs roughly $0.50 and comes in a 12-pack box. It’s worth noting that the K-Cups supplied are compostable and allergy and gluten-free.

It’s not often that you find allergy and gluten-free coffee, so we were pleasantly surprised. Furthermore, those who prefer mild roasts now have a top-tier alternative worthy of inclusion on the list.

On the other hand, the light roast is exclusively available for the Organic Breakfast Blend. On the other hand, the Organic French Roast has been darkly roasted. Finally, because K-Cups are compostable, they have a lower carbon footprint than most of the options listed.

The added convenience of the compostable pods and the absence of allergies comes at a cost. As a result, we discovered that the average cost of each K-Cup is around $0.50, which is quite expensive. Most other organic coffees cost around $0.30, so those trying to save money may opt for something else. In addition, because it lacks kosher certification, it may be inaccessible to Jews who follow their faith.

9. Death Wish strongest k cup

Last, we have Death Wish Coffees Organic K Cups, quickly known as the best organic coffee available when writing. This, we believe, is why their Valhalla Java has a smaller but incredibly dedicated following of organic coffee enthusiasts who like their super-strong coffee, which is difficult to obtain anywhere else at the time of writing.

The Death Wish coffee appears to have discovered its niche and is doing an excellent job of marketing it and developing its core customer base, who seem to be raving about it on social media and in one of the many independent reviews that have been done for it. In addition, although the physical K cups are not biodegradable, they are entirely recyclable, which helps reduce the product’s environmental impact.

The Valhalla Java is certified fair trade and USDA organic, making it the only coffee maker on the market right now focusing on the strong organic coffee Keurig K-cup coffee pods market. Because most coffee users prefer a milder mix, this limits the range’s potential expansion, but if you want your coffee stronger, the Death Wish K cups are worth checking out!

Why should you go organic?

Coffee is one of the world’s most popular beverages. Because of the popularity and demand, growers are incentivized to boost production. Some producers may use a variety of fertilizers, pesticides, fungicides, herbicides, and similar goods to accomplish this. Some people may even add fillers in coffee bags to enhance supply.

Similarly, hybrid coffee plants are an issue. The natural coffee plant grows best in the shade. Growing coffee in a dense forest or giving up a significant amount of coffee to grow trees is not a practical option for most growers. As a result, the majority of coffee plants are hybrids. These plants, designed to flourish in the open and yield berries, end up sacrificing flavor.

Organic coffee k cups are better

By turning organic, coffee farmers aim to improve the standards and quality of their harvest. It’s not just that the coffee is devoid of chemicals like pesticides, but it’s also grown naturally. In addition, organic K cups make efforts to be more ethical and sustainable as the focus shifts to sustainability.

This method is becoming more visible as the use of biodegradable coffee cups grows. As popular as they are, K-Cups hurt the environment due to the mountains of plastic they contribute to landfills. Biodegradable options are far better for the environment. Organic is also associated with healthy k cups, according to some. These statements about healthier coffee may be true given the lack of external chemicals.

Rather than taking dealers’ assertions at face value, it is essential to check for relevant certificates. The USDA Organic label is a good indicator. If I pay more for a better cup of coffee, I might as well make sure it’s worth it!

How to choose the best organic k-cups

Here’s how to choose the best organic coffee K-Cups after weighing your options. Notably, while following the same process, most people will produce different outcomes because the best organic coffee K-Cups for each person will depend on their preferences.

Type of beans

Arabica beans are twice as popular as robusta beans due to their fruity overtones and acidic flavor.

Arabica and Robusta are the two most common coffee beans grown today. However, there are others. According to International Coffee Organization statistics, Arabica shipments in the globe for the fiscal year ending June 2021 are nearly twice as high as Robusta exports.

This could explain why Arabica Organic Coffee K-Cups are more likely to be found than Robusta. Arabica beans are more aromatic, with fruity and flowery overtones and an acidic flavor. On the other hand, Robusta coffees have earthy tones, a peanut-like aftertaste, and less acidity.

Most people favor Arabica coffees, such as AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups, which justifies the market statistics. On the other hand, some people like Robusta coffee any day of the week. As a result, based on your preferred flavor profile, you can choose one or the other sort of coffee.


According to the World Population Review, coffee is farmed and exported by approximately 50 countries worldwide. Notably, these coffee origins have a significant impact on flavor.

Ethiopian coffee, for example, has subtle aftertastes of blueberry, bergamot, and jasmine. Brazilian coffee, on the other hand, has nutty notes and a pretty chocolatey flavor.

This is a common motif in practically every coffee-growing country, where the resulting coffee has a distinct flavor profile.

As a result, before purchasing K-Cups, always check the coffee origins. Notably, some of the coffees on our list are sourced from Peru, Indonesia, and Central American countries such as Honduras.

Green Mountain Coffee Sumatra Reserve K-Cups, for example, are made using beans from Indonesia.

Which certifications should you buy?

Buying organic coffee entails a few steps. First and foremost, be sure that it is certified organic coffee.

When you get certified organic coffee, you can rest assured that it was grown by growers who employed renewable resources to benefit the environment as much as possible.

You will also appreciate that organic coffee is produced without toxic pesticides or fertilizers.

If you have a gluten allergy, it is good to look for gluten-free, organic coffee.

It will be not only devoid of dangerous chemicals and pesticides but also be gluten-free. So if you’re looking for a healthy, gluten-free coffee option, this is a great option.

Another consideration in selecting the best organic k cup coffee is finding a fair trade certified brand.

When a coffee brand says it is fair trade, it indicates that the farm where it was grown paid its hardworking employees a fair wage in a safe environment.

Child labor is strictly forbidden when buying organic coffee from a certified fair-trade company.

Anyone Jewish will appreciate a kosher certification. This signifies that all of the ingredients are suitable for drinking coffee in a kosher manner.

On the package of your coffee, there is usually a logo with a “K” that indicates that it is suitable for a kosher lifestyle.

What’s USDA-certified organic?

You’ll note that all of the K cups on this page are USDA Certified Organic. The United States Department of Agriculture administers this program for certifying organic produce. A certification indicates that the coffee was acquired from farms that met the program’s requirements.

This certification has several prerequisites. One crucial criterion is that no synthetic chemical inputs be made to the soil for at least three years before certification. Chemical fertilizers, insecticides, fungicides, sewage sludge, and other substances fall into this group.

Included sites are subject to regular inspections and must conform to the requirements. Auditable production and sales data must be available. If a farm raises certified and non-certified products, the products should be kept separate. There are a few additional prerequisites, but these are the most significant.

Caffeinated or decaffeinated?

When looking for the best organic k cup of coffee, you should consider these certifications and whether or not you want it to be caffeinated.

If you don’t work well with caffeine – or if coffee keeps you up at night – you should make some changes.

For example, avoid drinking coffee after a specific time of day or go for a half-and-half organic coffee instead.

By mixing half caffeinated and half decaf coffee, you can fool your mind into thinking you’re drinking a fully caffeinated coffee. This is an excellent option for anyone with sleep or health problems due to coffee.

Furthermore, if you want to enjoy the taste of a smooth organic coffee without the caffeine effects, a decaf version may be your best option.

Which roast is best for you?

To determine the caffeine content of your organic coffee, look at the roast type. The most caffeine will be found in a mild roast. A medium roast will be less caffeinated than a light roast, but its flavor will be more balanced.

A more acidic flavor distinguishes light roasts. A dark roast has a harsh taste but has less caffeine than a light or medium roast. A light roast is a way to go if you’re searching for a highly caffeinated beverage to complement your early morning routine.

A basic rule of thumb is that the darker your coffee, the less caffeine it contains. So if you’re looking for a fantastic new organic coffee, check out these five mouth-watering Amazon options.


All of the K-Cups included in this tutorial are Keurig 2.0 compatible. Check the compatibility with your Keurig-branded brewer as well. Brewing will be tough if the K-Cup does not work with your machine. Fortunately, the abovementioned choices are compatible with both 1.0 and 2.0 brewers. However, things may be a little different when it comes to Keurig Vue machines.

Size of the pack

Pack size may also be an issue for home use. Single-person homes, for example, require smaller packs to meet their demands than multi-person families and households. As a result, keep that in mind when you click the buy button.


Are k-cups eco-friendly?

K-Cups are made from various plastic, aluminum, and plant-based biodegradable materials. As a result, some are more environmentally friendly than others. However, even those that aren’t composting are recyclable, and you can make them work without causing too much environmental damage.

How long does k-cup coffee stay fresh?

You have more than a year after buying a K-Cup pack to eat it. However, as with other coffees, the longer you wait, the lower the quality, taste, and aroma.


These five options are fantastic resources to use while choosing an organic coffee. Organic coffee should be certified to ensure you obtain the advertised product.

It is also essential to examine the roast of the coffee. Unless you pick decaf, the caffeine levels will be determined by the roast. You only need a mug and a Keurig machine now. Otherwise, you should be fine.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links. Remember to support us by purchasing through the Amazon/Walmart/Impact Radius links provided. Last update on 2024-04-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Disclosure: No compensation or free products were received in exchange for writing this review.


Editorial Staff

The editorial staff at Crazy Coffee Crave is a team of coffee enthusiasts & Baristas who enjoy the one thing we all think about as soon as we get up in the morning. Trusted by thousands of readers worldwide.